Re: companies with a lot of owners. Perhaps they are one of many of capitalism's hall of mirrors of responsibility avoidance, and perhaps in those cases, rather than saying 'so much the worse for responsibility', we could say 'so much the worse for the hall of mirrors'."
This feels like a loaded comment. I don’t think capitalism is meant to abdicate responsibility - quite the opposite, it generally forces people to have skin in the game (because of invested capital).
I may be simlply out of my depth here, I'm not that knowledteable about history and culture. But I have a theory that capitalism is a giant mechanism of responsibility avoidance.
E.g.: Communism and fascism are condemned for their atrocities, capitalism hides behind democracy - maybe some atrocity is presented as X and Y's fault, not capitalism's!
E.g. 2: LLCs. Why should liability be limited?
E.g. 3: If companies are "legal persons", then why don't they face penal consequences for their actions? It would be simple: just map criminal law sanctions to sanctions for companies. A life imprisonment corresponds to X, an imprisonment for N years corresponds to Y for N years, disqualification from public office corresponds to Z, community service to W, home detention to K, etc. Just make the mapping once and apply it to companies. I'm thinking non-monerary sanctions here, like for individuals.. Like, close for N years, or dissolve the company.
E.g. 4: In big companies... call this my uneducated guess, but I think nobody makes the explicit decision to e.g. kill babies. Maybe the CEO orders to increase sales by 15% in area A. I feel that if the system cared about companies' responsibility, we would say that if a company's structure makes it impossible to identify who decided, liability falls on the owners and/or the board and/or the senior executives (I'm undecided if it has to be all of them or a subset of them but I think the idea is clear).
I don't think this is quite right, although naturally democracies and capitalism diffuse responsibility, compared to tyrannies, monarchies, aristocracies, etc, where power is vested in a select few. To address your examples specifically,
1) Not really... many people blame 'capitalism' for inequality, alienation, etc.
2) Because that encourages innovation. Extremely few people would start companies or invest in them if they were personally liable. Would you invest your pension in the stock market, if every time a company defaults, creditors can come after your house?
3) and 4) Companies do face consequences and are often fined, and managers and shareholders can be criminally liable in certain circumstances.
Re: 1, maybe I'm in a bubble, but I see fascism and communism more commonly blamed than capitalism.
Re: 2, investing: I would not invest in them, and maybe that is the point.
Re: 2, starting companies: I don't know, I currently act as a freelancer and I don't have any limited reliability. If my business gets bigger and I start a full-sized organization, why should I enjoy LESS responsibility?
Re: 3-4, but I don't see company being imprisoned for 10 years, while individuals are.
To me it looks like the system protects organizations more than individuals.
Re: companies with a lot of owners. Perhaps they are one of many of capitalism's hall of mirrors of responsibility avoidance, and perhaps in those cases, rather than saying 'so much the worse for responsibility', we could say 'so much the worse for the hall of mirrors'."
This feels like a loaded comment. I don’t think capitalism is meant to abdicate responsibility - quite the opposite, it generally forces people to have skin in the game (because of invested capital).
I may be simlply out of my depth here, I'm not that knowledteable about history and culture. But I have a theory that capitalism is a giant mechanism of responsibility avoidance.
E.g.: Communism and fascism are condemned for their atrocities, capitalism hides behind democracy - maybe some atrocity is presented as X and Y's fault, not capitalism's!
E.g. 2: LLCs. Why should liability be limited?
E.g. 3: If companies are "legal persons", then why don't they face penal consequences for their actions? It would be simple: just map criminal law sanctions to sanctions for companies. A life imprisonment corresponds to X, an imprisonment for N years corresponds to Y for N years, disqualification from public office corresponds to Z, community service to W, home detention to K, etc. Just make the mapping once and apply it to companies. I'm thinking non-monerary sanctions here, like for individuals.. Like, close for N years, or dissolve the company.
E.g. 4: In big companies... call this my uneducated guess, but I think nobody makes the explicit decision to e.g. kill babies. Maybe the CEO orders to increase sales by 15% in area A. I feel that if the system cared about companies' responsibility, we would say that if a company's structure makes it impossible to identify who decided, liability falls on the owners and/or the board and/or the senior executives (I'm undecided if it has to be all of them or a subset of them but I think the idea is clear).
I don't think this is quite right, although naturally democracies and capitalism diffuse responsibility, compared to tyrannies, monarchies, aristocracies, etc, where power is vested in a select few. To address your examples specifically,
1) Not really... many people blame 'capitalism' for inequality, alienation, etc.
2) Because that encourages innovation. Extremely few people would start companies or invest in them if they were personally liable. Would you invest your pension in the stock market, if every time a company defaults, creditors can come after your house?
3) and 4) Companies do face consequences and are often fined, and managers and shareholders can be criminally liable in certain circumstances.
Re: 1, maybe I'm in a bubble, but I see fascism and communism more commonly blamed than capitalism.
Re: 2, investing: I would not invest in them, and maybe that is the point.
Re: 2, starting companies: I don't know, I currently act as a freelancer and I don't have any limited reliability. If my business gets bigger and I start a full-sized organization, why should I enjoy LESS responsibility?
Re: 3-4, but I don't see company being imprisoned for 10 years, while individuals are.
To me it looks like the system protects organizations more than individuals.