Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Griffin's avatar

This is a common perspective from the conservative side, but I think when looking more closely it is very apparent such a divide is not nearly so neat. Consider a few observations:

(1) People complain a lot about whiny progressives that don't better themselves, and you can certainly find these online, but what if you actually compare the average progressive and conservative. Progressives as a group achieve substantially higher levels of education and make substantially more money than conservatives as a group, and that is despite being overrepresented in less profit-maximizing degrees. Its such a stereotype that progressives are low-achieving compared to conservatives, but this just seems to be clearly untrue, in fact with very strong trends in the other direction. I think this is an incredibly serious problem that any "progressives are less responsible than conservatives" theory has to recon with. (note this could be selection, this could be causal, but either way it refutes the progressives aren't responsible theory).

(2) Progressive policy recommendations often seem to imply a greater faith in personal responsibility than conservative ones do. Consider a proposal to provide increased welfare to poor people. Progressives will often believe that recipients will at least partially use it to better their lives through things like stability, education, etc., while conservatives generally believe they will waste it or it will be actively detrimental by not pushing them through deprivation to earn more. If you think about a lot of progressive policy proposals in practice, they really do seem to need personal responsibility to actually make sense, so maybe they do believe in personal responsibility!

(3) Many issues between progressives and conservatives are something like "government needs to intervene to forbid people from doing this to themselves" where conservatives are for it and progressives against it. For example (including historical cases that most conservatives wouldn't support today) ban on gay marriage, ban on Marijuana, Ban on certain books, Bans on certain sex work, ban on flag burning, etc. These issues all seem to contradict the conservative "let people reap the fruits of their personal responsibility" theory, it is explicitly the conservatives rejecting personal responsibility and saying the government needs to be responsible by stepping in instead.

I would offer the alternative interpretation that

(i) Progressives tend to not associate personal responsibility with just deserts while conservatives do. Progressives are likely to claim that personal responsibility is a result of an amalgamation of factors outside of yourself and ultimately are no different than luck, skill, opportunity, or anything else in determining the moral worthiness of a person to benefit/suffer. Conservatives are more likely to claim that if a person works hard, is responsible, it is morally desirable for them to get better rewards than someone who does not work as hard and is irresponsible.

(ii) Progressives are more optimistic about personal responsibility. They think that in general people adopt bad habits because of lack of access to good environments, so bettering their environment betters their habits. Conservatives tend towards thinking good habits come about by necessity, so bettering a persons material conditions is more likely to worsen their habits. That is in short if you ask "how should one cultivate responsibility/beneficial behavior" the conservative responds "material insecurity" and the progressive responds "material security".

And obviously "progressive" and "conservative" are both extremely big tents with lots of diverse sets of belief contained within them. These are very much just hasty generalizations that have many particular exceptions.

I am hesitant to try to psychoanalyze people for their political positions, but one possible theory is that people get their views on society in general via mirror-imaging, believing that other people are basically like themselves. So a person who thinks "I became responsible because I had to overcome adversity" adopts the conservative mindset, and a person who thinks "I became responsible because I had the social opportunities and safety to explore my own development and recover from my failures" adopts the progressive mindset.

Note that this comment comes off more anti-conservative than I would normally write because I'm trying to refute your pro-conservative argument.

Alex's avatar

I consider myself progressive and your characterization of progressives as not caring about everyday injustices because they're all concerned about gaza or climate change or whatever strikes me as totally inaccurate and not based on reality, outside of the occasional terminally-online dipshit maybe. I think you are extrapolating from stupid twitter takes too much.

7 more comments...

Ready for more?