Bojack Horseman and Black Mirror are as different as two TV series can be. The former is an animated series featuring anthropomorphic animals and humans navigating their relationships and trauma. Black Mirror is a sci fi about dystopian misuses of technology. But the biggest difference is their core philosophy: Bojack ultimately emphasises the importance of personal responsibility, whereas Black Mirror suggests the individual is powerless in the face of societal and technological forces.
For example, in The Entire History of You, a man’s relationship falls apart after he views his wife’s recorded memories of an affair; Nosedive shows a woman’s life spiralling out of control in a world where daily interactions are rated, with the rating determining a person’s social standing; Hated in the Nation is about a hacker using robotic bees to murder online hate mobs; and Smithereens features a man who blames a social network for the car collision that killed his wife. The characters in these episodes often explicitly blame technology: The Entire History of You ends with the protagonist cutting open his neck to remove his memory-recording device, and in Smithereens the protagonist says
I heard that you make these things that way. Addictive. So that you can't take you eyes off them. Well, job done. Bit of user feedback for you there. Maybe factor that into your next update.
Bojack Horseman’s titular character was raised by unloving, distant, and cruel parents. He’s an alcoholic who lives on his past fame (at the beginning of the show at least) and who’s tormented by guilt. But while the show’s creators explore the sources of his destructive behaviour, they do not use them to excuse it: one of the most memorable scenes in the series is the dialogue between Bojack and his friend Todd, who tells him
You can't keep doing this! You can't keep doing shitty things and then feel bad about yourself like that makes it okay! You need to be better! BoJack, just stop. You are all the things that are wrong with you. It's not the alcohol, or the drugs, or any of the shitty things that happened to you in your career, or when you were a kid. It's you. Okay? It's you. Fuck, man, what else is there to say?
The contrasting philosophy between the two series is, I think, at the heart of the difference between conservatives and progressives. For example, it explains differing attitudes towards
Wealth re-distribution: if your fundamental premise is that individuals are in control of their destiny, it follows that you believe the fortunate deserve their fortune, and the unfortunate their lack thereof; and if you disagree with that premise, it’s normal that you should believe in equity of outcome.
Wokeism: wokeism is predicated on power imbalances that are impossible to counteract, and it waves away individuals’ agency: trigger warnings, concern over micro-aggression, and aversion to uninhibited free speech assume, to a large extent, that individuals exposed to unwelcome messaging or behaviour lack the resilience to cope with these, and so they need to be protected from them.
Regulation: progressives think consumers need to be protected — they cannot be trusted to make informed choices. They distrust the market because they think individuals are powerless compared to corporations.
Robert Jenrick’s stunt on the Tube: no-one on the Left has denied that people dodge fares on the tube; but plenty of people have commented that it’s absurd to care about insignificant things like this (even if addressing them is within the British government’s control) when there are children dying in Gaza (even though that’s outside the government’s control).
Progressives’ discomfort with personal responsibility stems from two sources: first, the aforementioned belief that societal forces are too strong for an individual to counteract; and second, that given the magnitude of the crises facing humanity (climate change, wars, inequality), caring about one’s own sphere of influence is petty and ultimately pointless: ‘why should I care about tidying my room, when climate change will kill me’.
I am a conservative, so I agree with Bojack’s philosophy much more than I do with Black Mirror’s. Not necessarily because it’s correct: after all, progressives are right about a great many things. Societal forces are immensely powerful, and, as Black Mirror suggests, individuals can hardly resist technological advances (with the exception of the Amish:
). The universe may well be deterministic, and everyone’s path may be inalterable. The first issue I take with progressivism is that the solutions it offers invalidate its own premise: if societal forces are inexorable, what’s the point of trying to counteract them? Progressives sense this paradox: it’s no accident that Black Mirror is bleak and rarely offers happy endings and glimmers of hope; and when it does, as is the case with Nosedive, it is when individuals affect change. In that episode, society at large doesn’t revolt and do away with its social credit rating mechanism. The protagonist begins to find peace by rejecting the system and her fake, wishy-washy persona. So, in my view, we cannot grant progressivism’s core assumption that individuals cannot control their destiny. If we do, we may as well do nothing. Instead, we should choose to believe that individuals have the power to change the world around them. Not necessarily alone, but by beginning movements that do. And if we grant that, then we should also expect of people the flipside of power: responsibility.
(One does not have to treat the question of individual agency as a case of absolutes: one can accept that individuals exercise some control over the destiny, but that there are forces that are much more powerful. No-one can possibly deny that a white boy born in England has better prospects than a baby born to a family without access to water or medicine. But it’s a question of degree: once you allow there is room for agency, you need to demand at least some exercise of that agency.
(Ancient Greeks reconciled agency with destiny with the saying ‘σύν Ἀθηνᾷ καί χεῖρας κίνει’ — 'move your hands along with Athena’, also rendered as ‘God helps those who help themselves’.))
Now, a progressive might counter-argue that an individual is powerless, unless they join a movement: this is why they might not care about getting their private life in order, but that there is still a point in engaging in politics, because there is strength in numbers. In other words, progressives do not necessarily think anything an individual does is pointless: it’s only pointless if their action has a limited scope. The standard conservative response to this counter-argument (‘why should anyone trust you with public matters if you can’t get your private life in order’) is compelling but not as strong as you might think: plenty of people who are a mess in private life do well in other spheres (William Pitt the Younger was extremely successful in managing the English economy, but died with debts of £2m in today’s money (can you imagine a modern PM with £2m in debt??)).
My response (which collectively forms my second objection to the progressive philosophy) is a bit more nuanced. First, do not underestimate the impact of small things. If you live your life well, if you’re kind, polite, considerate, honest, hard-working, and conscientious, you can have a bigger impact on other people than you might think. Even small acts of kindness — helping someone with their luggage in the Tube — can make someone’s day. Plus, this compounds when you start a family — if you have your act together, it’s more likely your children will do. Conversely, if you’re being irresponsible, because you think what you do in your private life doesn’t matter, the impact you have on the world around you is more harmful than you believe. If you throw rubbish out of your car window, you’re encouraging others to do the same. The reason high-trust societies work isn’t just that the government enforces the law: it’s that their citizens hold each other to account through their private behaviour.
(That said, state enforcement does matter, because if even a small minority believes they can get away with bad behaviour, that behaviour will spread — exactly because people imitate what they see. And so, if people see others shoplifting with impunity, at some point they will start wondering why they have to be the shmucks who pay (especially given that the prices they’re charged reflect the sales lost through theft).)
In short: virtue begets virtue and vice begets vice. So be virtuous.
Second, leave changing the world aside for a minute. Believing in agency and personal responsibility are good for personal wellbeing. All the policies and legislation and external interventions in the world won’t make a person happy if that person does not assume responsibility over their behaviour. This is at message at the heart of Bojack Horseman: there is no way to undo all the damage and hurt Bojack has experienced. His pain, however, explains but does not excuse his selfishness and weaknesses, and the harm these do to his friends. As Todd tells him, Bojack needs to stop feeling sorry for himself because of all the bad things that have happened to him (even though they are very real) and has to just be better. This is a hard message to give, and it does not help when it’s someone like me (that is, someone who’s never experienced hardship) giving it. But as I tell my children, you cannot control other people’s behaviour, and you cannot change everything that has already happened to you; you can control your own response and your own future actions.
Note also that when people talk about feelings of despair and powerlessness, they are misattributing them to big things like inequality and climate change and AI (it’s not technology that’s to blame for the protagonist’s failed marriage in The Entire History of You: technology is what makes him find out his wife was unfaithful, but not the cause of the lack of trust and communication between him and her). No doubt, these are big and scary enough to induce despair in everyone; so why don’t they? Because not everyone is equally susceptible to despair. As per that old prayer,
God, grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change, the courage to change the things I can, and the wisdom to know the difference.
Taking this to heart, and getting your own life in order will make you happier. You’ll find it easier building bonds with people. If you are dependable and kind, people will want to spend time with you; and conversely, if you’re not, you’ll find you won’t have many real friends. (I find that people tend to cluster: happy, functional people hang out with happy, functional people, and unhappy, dysfunctional people hang out with unhappy, dysfunctional people. I’m sure a lot of this is because of confounders, but surely there are causal relationships here too: happy people uplift those around them, and the effect becomes reinforced; and, sadly, even the kindest person in the world will at some point stop hanging out with someone who is destructive — so, destructive people end up being segregated out of positive circles.)
And as I wrote before, a lot of people turn to big ideas (religion, politics, other crusades) in an attempt to find meaning, but I think you can create meaning for yourself by trying to be better. Goodness becomes its own meaning and its own reward. It’s a bulwark against insecurity and feelings of being lost. You might think that helping someone carry a buggy down the steps in the tube is immaterial when AI might kill us all in five years; but, you can accomplish the former, whereas you can’t do much about the latter. And you’ll put a smile on someone’s face. That’s something.


This is a common perspective from the conservative side, but I think when looking more closely it is very apparent such a divide is not nearly so neat. Consider a few observations:
(1) People complain a lot about whiny progressives that don't better themselves, and you can certainly find these online, but what if you actually compare the average progressive and conservative. Progressives as a group achieve substantially higher levels of education and make substantially more money than conservatives as a group, and that is despite being overrepresented in less profit-maximizing degrees. Its such a stereotype that progressives are low-achieving compared to conservatives, but this just seems to be clearly untrue, in fact with very strong trends in the other direction. I think this is an incredibly serious problem that any "progressives are less responsible than conservatives" theory has to recon with. (note this could be selection, this could be causal, but either way it refutes the progressives aren't responsible theory).
(2) Progressive policy recommendations often seem to imply a greater faith in personal responsibility than conservative ones do. Consider a proposal to provide increased welfare to poor people. Progressives will often believe that recipients will at least partially use it to better their lives through things like stability, education, etc., while conservatives generally believe they will waste it or it will be actively detrimental by not pushing them through deprivation to earn more. If you think about a lot of progressive policy proposals in practice, they really do seem to need personal responsibility to actually make sense, so maybe they do believe in personal responsibility!
(3) Many issues between progressives and conservatives are something like "government needs to intervene to forbid people from doing this to themselves" where conservatives are for it and progressives against it. For example (including historical cases that most conservatives wouldn't support today) ban on gay marriage, ban on Marijuana, Ban on certain books, Bans on certain sex work, ban on flag burning, etc. These issues all seem to contradict the conservative "let people reap the fruits of their personal responsibility" theory, it is explicitly the conservatives rejecting personal responsibility and saying the government needs to be responsible by stepping in instead.
I would offer the alternative interpretation that
(i) Progressives tend to not associate personal responsibility with just deserts while conservatives do. Progressives are likely to claim that personal responsibility is a result of an amalgamation of factors outside of yourself and ultimately are no different than luck, skill, opportunity, or anything else in determining the moral worthiness of a person to benefit/suffer. Conservatives are more likely to claim that if a person works hard, is responsible, it is morally desirable for them to get better rewards than someone who does not work as hard and is irresponsible.
(ii) Progressives are more optimistic about personal responsibility. They think that in general people adopt bad habits because of lack of access to good environments, so bettering their environment betters their habits. Conservatives tend towards thinking good habits come about by necessity, so bettering a persons material conditions is more likely to worsen their habits. That is in short if you ask "how should one cultivate responsibility/beneficial behavior" the conservative responds "material insecurity" and the progressive responds "material security".
And obviously "progressive" and "conservative" are both extremely big tents with lots of diverse sets of belief contained within them. These are very much just hasty generalizations that have many particular exceptions.
I am hesitant to try to psychoanalyze people for their political positions, but one possible theory is that people get their views on society in general via mirror-imaging, believing that other people are basically like themselves. So a person who thinks "I became responsible because I had to overcome adversity" adopts the conservative mindset, and a person who thinks "I became responsible because I had the social opportunities and safety to explore my own development and recover from my failures" adopts the progressive mindset.
Note that this comment comes off more anti-conservative than I would normally write because I'm trying to refute your pro-conservative argument.
I consider myself progressive and your characterization of progressives as not caring about everyday injustices because they're all concerned about gaza or climate change or whatever strikes me as totally inaccurate and not based on reality, outside of the occasional terminally-online dipshit maybe. I think you are extrapolating from stupid twitter takes too much.